I thought nothing could come close to my Milani Liquid Eye liquid-like blackest black pencil eyeliner but boy was I wrong! This is the perfect dupe and even softer. I can smoothly line my waterline wouldn’t any fuss and the black really does show up. After it sets, it really doesn’t move especially on my watery lids. If you’re looking for a really black eyeliner that is handy, waterproof and smudge proof then look no further. This is it!
